What’s Wrong with Asking about Citizenship on the Census?

POLITICS & POLICY
A newly naturalized American citizen holds her new country’s flag and her naturalization papers as she is sworn in during a U.S. citizenship ceremony in Los Angeles (Mike Blake/Reuters)

A donnybrook has broken out over how the administration decided to add a citizenship question to the census. We’ll presumably learn more one way or the other, but it’s worth asking why it is considered such a scandal to ask about citizenship, which is a question on other government surveys and isn’t new on the census. Here is the Census Bureau itself describing what it asks as part of the very important, ongoing American Community Survey and why:

We ask questions about a person’s place of birth, citizenship, and year of entry into the United States to create data about citizens, noncitizens, and the foreign-born population.

Agencies and policymakers use our published statistics to set and evaluate immigration policies and laws, understand the experience of different immigrant groups, and enforce laws, policies, and regulations against discrimination based on national origin. These statistics also help tailor services to accommodate cultural differences.

And explaining the origins of these questions:

Citizenship originated with the 1820 Census, place of birth originated with the 1850 Census, and year of entry originated with the 1890 Census. They transferred to the ACS in 2005 when it replaced the decennial census long form.

Rich Lowry is the editor of National Review. He can be reached via email: comments.lowry@nationalreview.com. 

You Might Like

Articles You May Like

“Antiracist” Boston doctors say white patients should be left untreated to die, while black patients go to the front of the line
​Investigation demanded after Black Lives Matter co-founder exposed for ‘real estate-buying binge’​
Minnesota Police Shooting Victim Daunte Wright a Young Father and Gang-Banger, Pictured with His Gun
Irony Alert: Dr. Fauci Is the Most Effective Anti-Vaxxer Ever
Video of ‘awkward’ interaction between Andrew Yang and a New Yorker may derail his mayoral campaign

Leave a Comment - No Links Allowed:

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *